Criminology and Criminal Justice — Overview
News
Preventive Justice Project hosts Oxford-UNSW postgraduate workshop
On Monday 5th December 2011, Andrew Ashworth, Lucia Zedner and Patrick Tomlin hosted a Postgraduate Workshop at the Centre for Criminology on ‘Anti-Terror Laws and Preventive Justice’ jointly with colleagues George Williams, Andrew Lynch and Fergal Davis from the Gilbert + Tobin Centre of Public Law, University of New South Wales. [more…]
Can a trust-based criminal policy lead to fewer crimes?
Oxford Sociology has joined a major research project funded by the European Commission. In November 2011, €2.7M were awarded by the European Commission for research into criminal policy and the promotion of trust in justice. [more…]
Seminar on Preventive Justice
All Souls played host on 15-16 September 2011 to a major inter-disciplinary workshop organized by Professor Andrew Ashworth, Professor Lucia Zedner and Dr Patrick Tomlin as part of their three-year AHRC research project ‘on Preventive Justice. [more…]
Conference on Anti-Social Behaviour and the Courts
Dr Jane Donoghue, Centre for Criminology, ran a halfday conference on Anti-Social Behaviour and the Courts in England and Wales at New College on 22 March 2011. [more…]
Appointment to new sentencing council
Oxford University’s Professor Julian Roberts has been appointed to a new national body set up to ensure a consistent approach to sentencing. [more…]
Discussion Group
These self-sustaining groups are an essential part of the life of our graduate school. They are organised in some cases by graduate students and in others by Faculty members and meet regularly during term, typically over a sandwich lunch, when one of the group presents work in progress or introduces a discussion of a particular issue or new case. They may also encompass guest speakers from the faculty and beyond.
Publications
Showing all[*] publications sorted by type, then year, author, title [change this]
Showing all 53 Criminology and Criminal Justice publications currently held in our database
Change to sort them by year | title | name OR
Show only Recent | Selected publications
Journal Articles
2010
A Ashworth, 'Sentencing Guidelines and the Sentencing Council' (2010) Criminal Law Review 389
A critical assessment of the provisions of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 relating to sentencing guidelines and the new Sentencing Council.
2007
G.Robinson and R Burnett, 'Experiencing modernisation: frontline probation perspectives on the transition to a national offender management service' (2007) 54 Probation Journal 318
L Zedner and Ian Loader, 'Police beyond Law' (2007) vol.10, no.1 New Criminal Law Review 142
Critical review essay of Markus Dubber The Police Power: Patriarchy and the Foundations of American Government.
ISBN: 1933-4192
2006
M Bosworth, 'Self-harm in women's prisons' (2006) 5 Criminology and Public Policy 157
Abstract: This is a brief overview of the literature and issues associated with self-harm in women's prisons. It served as an introduction to a longer paper by someone else and a response both of which I commissioned and edited for the journal. The journal is one of the official publications of the American Society of Criminology.
R Burnett and S Maruna, 'The kindness of prisoners: strengths-based resettlement in theory and in action' (2006) 6 Criminology and Criminal Justice 83
L Zedner, 'Liquid Security: Managing the market for crime control' (2006) 6 (2) Criminology and Criminal Justice 267
This article examines attempts to regulate the growing private security market drawing on the literatures of economic analysis of law and regulation.
ISBN: 1748-8958
L Zedner, 'Neither safe nor sound? The perils and possibilities of risk' (2006) 48/3 Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice 423
Examines the implications of risk reduction as a basis for penal policy and explores how adjacent social scientific disciplines conceive, deploy, and respond to risk.
ISBN: 1707-7753
2005
A Ashworth and Elaine Player, 'Criminal Justice Act 2003: the Sentencing Principles' (2005) 68 Modern Law Review 822
A critical review of the major sentencing provisions introduced by the Criminal Justice Act 2003.
ISBN: 0026-7961
2004
A Ashworth, 'Criminal Justice Reform: Principles, Human Rights and Public Protection' (2004) Criminal Law Review 516
Critique of foundations for recent criminal justice legislation
ISBN: 0011-135X
M Bosworth, 'Theorizing Race and Imprisonment: Towards a New Penality' (2004) 12 Critical Criminology 221
Abstract: This is a comparison of historical and contemporary issues to do with race and prisons in the UK, France and the USA.
2003
C Hoyle, Roderick Hill, Karen Cooper and Richard Young, 'Introducing Restorative Justice to the Police Complaints System: Close Encounters of the Rare Kind.' (2003) Occasional Paper No. 20. Centre for Criminological Research 35
Abstract: This report presents a discussion of data on the introduction of restorative processes in the police complaints system.
ISBN: 0 947811 19 2
2001
C Hoyle, 'Restorative Justice in the Thames Valley: Changes in the Complaints and Discipline Process,' (2001) 133 Prison Service Journal 37
Abstract: A description of the recent move towards using restorative justice for the complaints and discipline process in the Thames Valley.
ISBN: 0300-3558
C Hoyle, Andrew Sanders, Rod Morgan and Ed Cape, 'Victim Impact Statements: Don't work, Can't work' (2001) June Criminal Law Review 437
Abstract: This article contributes to the debate in the Criminal Law Review between Erez and Ashworth on victim impact statement schemes (VIS). The authors argue that VIS are misconceived in principle and unsatisfactory in practice.
ISBN: 0011 135X
Books
2011
D. Faulkner and R Burnett, Where Next for Criminal Justice? (The Policy Press 2011)
2010
A Ashworth, Sentencing and Criminal Justice (5th edn, Cambridge University Press 2010)
A Ashworth and Mike Redmayne, The Criminal Process (Oxford University Press 2010)
2008
A Ashworth and L H Zedner, Defending the Criminal Law: Reflections on the Changing Character of Crime, Procedure and Sanctions (2, Criminal Law and Philosophy 2008)
DOI: 10.1007/s11572-007-9033-2
Re-assessment of the trend away from traditional criminal law and criminal procedure, and re-assertion of the normative significance of criminal law principles and protections.
2005
A Ashworth and Andrew von Hirsch, Proportionate Sentencing: Exploring the Principles (Oxford University Press 2005)
An exploration and refinement of the application of the proportionality principle in the theory of punishment and sentencing.
ISBN: 0-19-927260-3
A Ashworth and others, The Criminal Process (Oxford University Press 2005)
The third (expanded) edition of a critical text on the English criminal process and criminal procedure.
ISBN: 0-19-927338-3
2002
M Bosworth, The US Federal Prison System (Sage Publications 2002)
Abstract: This book pulls together scholarly research, government publications and first hand accounts to provide the first overview of policy and practice in the US Federal Prison system. It also contains an appendix listing and describing all federal prisons. It is a cross-over book, designed for prison researchers, prisoners and those who work with them. It was positively reviewed in academic journals.
ISBN: 0-7619-2304-7
Chapters
2011
A Ashworth, 'Criminal Justice, not Criminology?' in Mary Bosworth and Carolyn Hoyle (eds), What is Criminology? (Oxford University Press 2011)
An attempt to discuss the distinctions and interrelations between criminology, criminal justice and criminal law.
ISBN: 978-0-19-957182-6
2008
C Hoyle, 'Restorative Justice, Victims and the Police' in T Newburn (ed), Handbook of Policing, 2nd edn. (Willan Publishing 2008)
Abstract: This chapter explores the ways in which the police in the UK use the principles of restorative justice in their encounters with victims and offenders, adult and juvenile. It argues that there are practical and philosophical objections to the police involvement in restorative justice, and that these, at lesat in part, explain wy there seems to be less restorative activity in the UK in 2008 that there was at teh start of the twenty-first century
ISBN: 978-1-84392-323-7
2007
A Ashworth, 'Plea-Bargaining, Pragmatism and Rights' in H. Muller-Dietz, E. Muller, K.-L. Kunz, H. Radtke, G. Britz, C. Momsen, H. Koriath (eds), Festschrift fur Heike Jung (Nomos 2007)
Exploring the compatibility of plea bargaining with the presumption of innocence.
ISBN: 978-3-8329-2537-6
M Bosworth, 'Identity, Citizenship and Punishment' in Mary Bosworth and Jeanne Flavin (eds), Race, gender and punishment: From colonialism to the war on terror (Rutgers University Press 2007)
Abstract: Chapter in book I coedited on race, gender and punishment. Analysis of recent legislation in the USA.
ISBN: 0-8135-3904-8
R Burnett, Baker, K. and Roberts, C., 'Assessment, supervision and intervention: fundamental practice in probation' in L. Gelsthorpe and R. Morgan (eds.) (eds), Handbook of Probation (Willan 2007)
L Zedner and Carolyn Hoyle, 'Victims, Victimization, and the Criminal Process' in M Maguire, R Morgan & R Reiner (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Criminology (Oxford University Press 2007)
Authoritative overview of the literature and research on victims and their role in the criminal process for the key criminological textbook in the field.
ISBN: 978-0-19-920543-1
2006
L Zedner, 'Opportunity makes the Thief-Taker: the influence of economic analysis on crime control' in T Newburn and P Rock (eds), The Politics of Crime Control (Oxford University Press 2006)
An appraisal of the impact of economic analysis/rational choice theory on criminal justice politics and Home Office policy making.
ISBN: 0-19-920840-9
L Zedner, 'Punishment and the Plurality of Privacy Interests' in E Claes and A Duff (eds), Privacy and the Criminal Law ( 2006)
Questions the status of privacy as a right and attempts to articulate the range of interests that arise when reference is made to privacy.
ISBN: 90-5095-545-2
2005
R Burnett, 'Youth offending teams' in T. Bateman and J. Pitts (eds), Companion to Youth Justice (Russell House Publishing 2005)
2003
R Young and C Hoyle, 'New Improved Restorative Justice?: Action-Research and the Thames Valley Initiative in Restorative Cautioning' in A von Hirsch, A Bottoms, J Roberts, K Roach and M Schiff (eds), Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice: Competing or Complementary Paradigms? (Hart Publishing 2003)
Abstract: Empirical research by the authors is used to illuminate the developing practice of police-led restorative justice in the UK.
ISBN: 1-84113-273-X
C Hoyle and Richard Young, 'Restorative Justice and Punishment' in S. McConville (ed), The Use of Punishment (Willan Publishing 2003)
Abstract: This chapter considers the development of restorative justice, its applications, its relationship with state justice, its relationship with vengeance and punishment, and some interconnected philosophical issues.
ISBN: 1-84392-033-6
C Hoyle and Richard Young, 'Restorative Justice, Victims and the Police' in T Newburn (ed), Handbook of Policing (Willan Publishing. 2003)
Abstract: This chapter explores the various ways in which the police are experimenting with the principles of restorative justice in the United Kingdom and draws on empirical research conducted by the authors.
ISBN: 1-84392-020-4
2002
C Hoyle and Richard Young, 'Restorative Justice: Assessing the Prospects and Pitfalls' in M McConville and G Wilson (eds), The Handbook of the Criminal Justice Process (Oxford University Press 2002)
Abstract: An assessment of the prospects and pitfalls of restorative justice.
ISBN: 0-19-925395-1
Edited books
2007
M Bosworth and Jeanne Flavin (eds), Race, gender and punishment: From colonialism to the war on terror (Rutgers University Press 2007)
Abstract: I contribute a chapter, plus a co-written introduction and conclusion. This is a collection of original essays on the history, theory and contemporary format of race, gender and punishment in the US.
ISBN: 0-8135-3904-8
2006
L Zedner and Benjamin Goold (eds), Crime and Security (Ashgate 2006)
Edited volume of leading articles in the field selected and introduced by us.
ISBN: 0 7546 2600 8
2005
M Bosworth (ed), Encyclopedia of Prisons and Correctional Facilties, Volume One and Two. (Sage Reference 2005)
Abstract: This two volume work was awarded Best Reference 2005 by the Library Journal. I contribute some entries, as well as an introduction.
2002
C Hoyle and Richard Young (eds), New Visions of Crime Victims (Hart Publishing 2002)
Abstract: An innovative edited collection of original theoretical analyses and previously unpublished empirical research on criminal victimisation. I edited this with Richard Young, wrote a chapter and a preface.
ISBN: 1-84113-280-2
Reports
2012
M Bosworth and B Kellezi, 'Quality of Life in Detention: Results from the MQLD Questionnaire Data Collected in IRC Yarl’s Wood, IRC Tinsley House and IRC Brook House, August 2010 – June 2011.' (2012) Centre for Criminology
2004
C Hoyle, A Wilcox and R Young, Two-year Resanctioning Study: A Comparison of Restorative and Traditional Cautions (2004) 57 Home Office 1
Abstract: This study reports the results of a 24 month resanctioning study of traditional and restorative cautions. It compared the resanctioning rates of over 29,000 offenders in the 3 police forces (2 using restorative cautions and 2 using the traditional process). No evidence was found to suggest that restorative cautioning resulted in a statistically significantly reduction in the resanctioning rate or the frequency or seriousness of offending.
ISBN: 1 84473 479X
2003
C Hoyle, Roderick Hill, Karen Cooper and Richard Young, 'Meeting Expectations: The Application of Restorative Justice to the Police Complaints Process' (2003) Occasional Paper No. 21, Centre for Criminological Research 83
Abstract: This report presents the findings of a two-year study examining the use of restorative justice within the police complaints system.
ISBN: 0 947811 20 6
2002
C Hoyle, R Young and R Hill, 'Proceed with Caution: An Evaluation of the Thames Valley Police Initiative in Restorative Cautioning' (2002) Joseph Rowntree Foundation 85
Abstract: This report on the findings of a three-year study conducted in the Thames Valley provides unique insight into the development and achievements of the first large-scale restorative justice programme in the UK.
ISBN: 1-84263-071-7
Courses
The courses we offer in this field are:
Undergraduate
FHS - Final Year (Phase III)
The degree is awarded on the basis of nine final examinations at the end of the three-year course (or four years in the case of Law with Law Studies in Europe). Phase II of the Final Honour School includes the first and second term of the final year; the Final Examinations are taken in the third term of the final year.
[less]
Criminal Justice and Penology (not offered in 2011-12)
This course offers an opportunity to study the phenomenon of crime and the ways it is dealt with by the criminal justice and penal systems. The subject is approached from the socio-legal, philosophical, historical and empirical perspectives. The aim of the course is to provide students with a sound analytical understanding of some central developments and debates relating to this subject.
An essential requirement is an understanding of: the value and limitations of official statistics and research relating to the dimensions of crime; the exercise of discretion by the police and the courts; the characteristics of offenders and of persons convicted; the punishments imposed and the effects of these punishments on the conduct of offenders and other citizens. Naturally, this entails a willingness, and some ability, to discuss the merits of research and to use statistical evidence in analysing a problem. But it should be noted that students are not expected to acquire a sophisticated knowledge of research methods, nor are advanced mathematical skills called for. There is no single textbook, but clear guidance is provided to students on core reading materials, which include research reports, scholarly journal articles and chapters from books, as well as proposals for reform from pressure groups and government.
The course includes an assessment of the scope and different manifestations of criminal behaviour, and goes on to examine the processes of the criminal justice system prior to conviction - police practices in relation to the recording of crime, arrest and charging of suspects; prosecution; and plea negotiations. Sentencing is approached from a consideration of the role of the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, particularly in the extent to which it has established principles to guide the courts in the exercise of their discretion. Proposals for reforming the sentencing structure and process are evaluated, as are empirical studies of judicial decision-making and sentencing disparities. Some philosophical issues connected with the justifications of punishment implicit in sentencing, parole, preventive detention, and other penal practices affecting an offender’s liberty, are discussed.
Questions of penal policy for adult offenders are explored in some depth. Among the topics usually covered are: the organisation, control and inspection of prisons; the nature of prison conditions and regimes and the changing justifications for them; the role of prison staff; security, control and justice in penal institutions; the effects of attempts to rehabilitate prisoners; the problems of dealing with habitual and dangerous criminals and with young adult offenders; the status and rights of prisoners; the early release of offenders through parole; the spread of noncustodial penalties and their impact on the prison population and recidivism; and the assessment of the incapacitative and general deterrent functions of punishment.
Special consideration is given to evaluating the development of juvenile justice and the measures which have evolved to deal specifically with children and young persons. Attention is also paid to the role of the victim and to restorative justice. The extent to which the operation of the criminal justice system involves unfair discrimination against citizens on the grounds of race or gender is also explored, with some tutors incorporating this question into all of the other issues studied. Indeed, while the teaching is organised into discrete topics, it should be emphasised that much of the material covered in one topic has implications for issues highlighted in other parts of the course.
Although the course is intended to be of general interest it should prove to be particularly useful to those who are contemplating work in a criminal practice or in any branch of the criminal justice system. It will also be good preparation for those who may wish to proceed to postgraduate study in criminology or criminal justice.
[less]
Criminology and Criminal Justice
Why are criminal laws made? Why are they broken? How do we, and how should we, react to the breaking of criminal laws? These three questions are the stuff of criminology. They also occupy a central and controversial place in public and political debates about the condition and future of contemporary liberal democratic societies. This course provides students with the chance to study them in depth.
Criminology and Criminal Justice offers students an opportunity to study crime and the ways in which it is dealt with by the criminal justice and penal systems. It enables students to explore the nature of crime and its control by examining the issues at stake using the resources of legal, penal and social theory. It also offers students the chance to think about crime as a social phenomenon and to explore using criminological research and analysis how criminal justice and penal systems operate in practice.
[less]
Diploma in Legal Studies
A one-year sample of courses from our BA programmes, aimed only at students visiting from our partner universities.
[less]
Criminal Justice and Penology (not offered in 2011-12)
This course offers an opportunity to study the phenomenon of crime and the ways it is dealt with by the criminal justice and penal systems. The subject is approached from the socio-legal, philosophical, historical and empirical perspectives. The aim of the course is to provide students with a sound analytical understanding of some central developments and debates relating to this subject.
An essential requirement is an understanding of: the value and limitations of official statistics and research relating to the dimensions of crime; the exercise of discretion by the police and the courts; the characteristics of offenders and of persons convicted; the punishments imposed and the effects of these punishments on the conduct of offenders and other citizens. Naturally, this entails a willingness, and some ability, to discuss the merits of research and to use statistical evidence in analysing a problem. But it should be noted that students are not expected to acquire a sophisticated knowledge of research methods, nor are advanced mathematical skills called for. There is no single textbook, but clear guidance is provided to students on core reading materials, which include research reports, scholarly journal articles and chapters from books, as well as proposals for reform from pressure groups and government.
The course includes an assessment of the scope and different manifestations of criminal behaviour, and goes on to examine the processes of the criminal justice system prior to conviction - police practices in relation to the recording of crime, arrest and charging of suspects; prosecution; and plea negotiations. Sentencing is approached from a consideration of the role of the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, particularly in the extent to which it has established principles to guide the courts in the exercise of their discretion. Proposals for reforming the sentencing structure and process are evaluated, as are empirical studies of judicial decision-making and sentencing disparities. Some philosophical issues connected with the justifications of punishment implicit in sentencing, parole, preventive detention, and other penal practices affecting an offender’s liberty, are discussed.
Questions of penal policy for adult offenders are explored in some depth. Among the topics usually covered are: the organisation, control and inspection of prisons; the nature of prison conditions and regimes and the changing justifications for them; the role of prison staff; security, control and justice in penal institutions; the effects of attempts to rehabilitate prisoners; the problems of dealing with habitual and dangerous criminals and with young adult offenders; the status and rights of prisoners; the early release of offenders through parole; the spread of noncustodial penalties and their impact on the prison population and recidivism; and the assessment of the incapacitative and general deterrent functions of punishment.
Special consideration is given to evaluating the development of juvenile justice and the measures which have evolved to deal specifically with children and young persons. Attention is also paid to the role of the victim and to restorative justice. The extent to which the operation of the criminal justice system involves unfair discrimination against citizens on the grounds of race or gender is also explored, with some tutors incorporating this question into all of the other issues studied. Indeed, while the teaching is organised into discrete topics, it should be emphasised that much of the material covered in one topic has implications for issues highlighted in other parts of the course.
Although the course is intended to be of general interest it should prove to be particularly useful to those who are contemplating work in a criminal practice or in any branch of the criminal justice system. It will also be good preparation for those who may wish to proceed to postgraduate study in criminology or criminal justice.
[less]
Postgraduate
BCL
Punishment, Security and the State
The proposed course aims to provide an in-depth understanding of the theoretical underpinnings, justifications, and contemporary practices of punishment and security. The subject is approached from criminological, socio-legal, philosophical, and historical perspectives. The course explores the role of the state in the exercise of its most coercive functions against individual citizens – whether punishing those found guilty of criminal wrongdoing or taking security measures against those deemed to pose a risk to the safety of the public and the nation. In Michaelmas Term it will focus on ‘why we punish’ by examining major debates in penal theory concerning the justification and rationale for punishment (not least desert theory and its critics, communicative and consequentialist theories). The second half of the term will consider ‘how we punish’ by exploring diverse social, economic and political aspects of punishment and examining whether it is possible to do justice to difference. In Hilary Term the focus will shift from punishment to the pursuit of security and critically examine what is meant by security (whether, for example, as pursuit, commodity, or public good). Successive seminars will consider whether the growth of markets in private security and the development of communal and personal security provision evidence the fragmentation or dispersal of state power. They will go on to examine exercises in state sovereignty in the name of risk management, counterterrorism, and migration and border control. These reassertions of state power permit significant intrusions into individual freedom and the deployment of exceptional measures and the course will address important questions about the limits of legality and the balancing of liberty and security. In Trinity Term two final seminars will provide an opportunity for critical reflection and engagement with issues raised throughout the course. The first will examine the case for ‘civilizing security’ and consider how security should be pursued, distributed, and governed and by whom; the second returns to the question of punishment to explore the notion of penal excess and the case for penal moderation.
[less]
MJur
Punishment, Security and the State
The proposed course aims to provide an in-depth understanding of the theoretical underpinnings, justifications, and contemporary practices of punishment and security. The subject is approached from criminological, socio-legal, philosophical, and historical perspectives. The course explores the role of the state in the exercise of its most coercive functions against individual citizens – whether punishing those found guilty of criminal wrongdoing or taking security measures against those deemed to pose a risk to the safety of the public and the nation. In Michaelmas Term it will focus on ‘why we punish’ by examining major debates in penal theory concerning the justification and rationale for punishment (not least desert theory and its critics, communicative and consequentialist theories). The second half of the term will consider ‘how we punish’ by exploring diverse social, economic and political aspects of punishment and examining whether it is possible to do justice to difference. In Hilary Term the focus will shift from punishment to the pursuit of security and critically examine what is meant by security (whether, for example, as pursuit, commodity, or public good). Successive seminars will consider whether the growth of markets in private security and the development of communal and personal security provision evidence the fragmentation or dispersal of state power. They will go on to examine exercises in state sovereignty in the name of risk management, counterterrorism, and migration and border control. These reassertions of state power permit significant intrusions into individual freedom and the deployment of exceptional measures and the course will address important questions about the limits of legality and the balancing of liberty and security. In Trinity Term two final seminars will provide an opportunity for critical reflection and engagement with issues raised throughout the course. The first will examine the case for ‘civilizing security’ and consider how security should be pursued, distributed, and governed and by whom; the second returns to the question of punishment to explore the notion of penal excess and the case for penal moderation.
[less]
People
Criminology and Criminal Justice teaching is organized by a Subject Group convened by:
Rachel Condry: UL in Criminology
in conjunction with:
Andrew Ashworth, QC: Vinerian Professor of English Law
Mary Bosworth: Reader in Criminology
Carolyn Hoyle: Professor of Criminology
Liora Lazarus: CUF Lecturer
Ian Loader: Professor of Criminology
Nicola Palmer: Junior Research Fellow in Global Justice
Julian Roberts: Professor of Criminology
Lucia Zedner: Professor of Criminal Justice
Also working in this field, but not involved in its teaching programme:
Clara Feliciati: DPhil Law student

