From real victims to synthetic violations: regulating AI-generated child sexual abuse material in China and the West

Speaker(s):

Guangxing Zhu is an Associate Professor of Criminal Law at the School of Criminal Justice, China University of Political Science and Law.

Series:

Chinese Law Discussion Group

Associated with:

Chinese Law Discussion Group
Plus roundal icon Add to calendar

Abstract

Traditional Child Sexual Abuse Material (CSAM) is widely prosecuted in Western jurisdictions as an offense against personal rights, predicated on the existence of real children who suffer sexual exploitation. However, the advent of generative AI has destabilized this traditional legal foundation. Generative AI enables the creation of synthetic CSAM—ranging from deepfake face-swapping of actual children to entirely virtual, realistic depictions—without immediate harm to a physical victim. This raises critical questions about the justification and appropriate scope of criminal law in regulating these AI-generated materials. This presentation provides a comparative analysis of the diverging regulatory and judicial trajectories emerging in the West and China. It contrasts Western legal struggles regarding the "victimless crime" dilemma and free expression constraints with China’s distinctive approach. Unlike Western framings of individual personal rights violations, China’s regulatory path is based on a framework that categorizes synthetic sexual content, including CSAM, as a sub-type of obscene material, a classification that makes regulation an effort to safeguard social management order, a clear departure from Western principles. This approach is exemplified by recent Chinese criminal cases concerning AI face-swapping, 'jailbroken' generative AI for mass obscenity production, and the dissemination of tools and tutorials for creating obscene material. While these cases do not directly involve CSAM, the judicial principles established therein are fully applicable to CSAM-type cases. Based on these cases, the paper argues that China’s judiciary has rejected the defense of technical neutrality where developers or facilitators exert substantive control over, or actively facilitate, the generation of illegal content, regardless of whether a physical victim exists for the specific act of production. Consequently, Chinese regulation prioritizes the prevention of societal harm and the maintenance of public morality over potential claims to technical innovation or individual expression, thus defining a regulatory path that criminalizes synthetic CSAM as a fundamental threat to social order, a dynamic distinct from the victim-centric debates dominant in the West.

Speaker Biography

Guangxing Zhu is an Associate Professor of Criminal Law at the School of Criminal Justice, China University of Political Science and Law, where she also serves as Vice-Director of the Department of Criminal Law. She holds a PhD in Criminal Law from Tilburg University (2018), where she was a researcher at the International Victimology Institute Tilburg (Intervict). Her research expertise spans criminal law and technology, criminology, sexual offences, gender-based legal issues, and the protection of vulnerable victims and children. She is widely published in both Chinese and English, including a monograph published by Maklu Publishers in 2022. Alongside her academic career, she is a practicing criminal defence lawyer and legal commentator. She is currently a Visiting Scholar at the Faculty of Law, University of Oxford (2025–2026).