Policy option 2
Establish that the deployment and operation of an algorithmic system shall be lawful only if:
a. The deployment and operation of the system meets at least one of the following requirements:
(i). It is intrinsically connected to and strictly necessary for the performance of the contract of employment or in order to take steps which are strictly necessary for entering into a contract of employment;
(ii) It is necessary for compliance with a legal obligation to which the employment is subject; or
(iii) It is necessary in order to protect the vital interest of the worker or of another natural person.
b. The algorithmic management system is capable of achieving these goals in a proportionate manner.
What does this mean in practice?
- Requires that processing personal data for algorithmic management must rely on one of the following legal bases: performance of or entering into an employment contract, legal obligation, or to protect the vital interests of the data subject/another natural person.
- Bans the use of consent, legitimate interests, or public interest as legal bases for algorithmic management.
- Introduces a proportionality test to show that algorithmic management systems meet their stated goals.
Real-world examples of policy option 2
Data protection law: data controllers can only lawfully carry out automated decision-making, including decisions based on profiling, by relying on limited legal bases, including (i) performance of or entering into a contract, (ii) authorised by law, or (iii) explicit consent. If the processing involves special category data, the only lawful bases are explicit consent or substantial public interest (EU GDPR, article 22(2)-(3)). However, consent is unlikely to be relied upon in practice, since guidelines state that power imbalances mean that ‘employees are almost never in a position to freely give, refuse or revoke consent’ (Article 29 Working Party Guidelines on Consent)
Labour law: digital labour platforms should not process platform workers’ data on the basis of consent (Platform Work Directive, recital 39)
This site is part of a project that has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No. 947806).
If you have any questions or feedback about this site or our research, please get in touch by emailing ai.work@law.ox.ac.uk.