Policy option 6
A right to decisions based on accurate facts and valid decision-making processes should be realised in the context of algorithmic management. To this end:
Establish individual rights regarding decisions taken or supported by algorithmic management systems; viz, the rights for an individual affected by such a decision to:
(a) request and receive a written explanation of the facts, circumstances, and reasons leading to the decision;
(b) contest the decision;
(c) discuss, supplement, and clarify these facts, circumstances, and reasons with a competent authorised human;
(d) request and receive a human review of the decision in light of the above; and
(e) have the decision rectified if the facts, circumstances, and/or reasons leading to it are found to be erroneous or unlawful.
What does this mean in practice?
- Mandates that algorithmic management is based on accurate facts and valid decision-making processes.
- Grants workers the right to contest automated decisions, the right to explanation, the right to human review, and the right to an accurate decision.
- Imposes an obligation on employers to rectify erroneous or unlawful decisions.
Real-world examples of policy option 6
Data protection law: grants data subjects the right to rectify inaccurate personal data (EU GDPR, art 16). Data subjects are also granted the right to obtain human intervention, express their point of view, contest, (EU GDPR, art 22(3)) and obtain an explanation of an automated decision (EU AI Act, art 15(1)(h)).
AI Act: requires that high-risk AI systems (e.g., those used in employment, worker management and access to self-employment) are designed and developed to achieve an appropriate level of accuracy and robustness throughout their lifecycle (EU AI Act, art 15).
Labour law in California: employers must promptly correct inaccurate data and review/adjust any employment-related decisions or automated decision-making system outputs that were partially or solely based on this inaccurate information (California Bill AB-1651, 2021-2022, s1532)
his site is part of a project that has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No. 947806).
If you have any questions or feedback about this site or our research, please get in touch by emailing ai.work@law.ox.ac.uk.