Policy option 3
- Establish obligations for employers to notify affected individuals of algorithmic management systems. Specifically:
a. Information regarding the use of algorithmic management systems shall be provided by the employer to all affected individuals at three points in time in relation to the employment relationship:
(i) at the earliest technically feasible time during the employment application process;
(ii) at the point at which a contract of employment is offered to a prospective employee; and
(iii) at regular intervals throughout the duration of the employment relationship (at least once a year), in the event of a change in the risk posed by the system, and at any time upon request.
b. The information to be provided could include:
(i) the existence of any algorithmic systems used in the process of monitoring, evaluating, or managing individuals or work, including, but not limited to, fully automated decision-making systems and scoring or evaluation systems whose outputs are used by human decision-makers;
(ii) the nature, purpose, and scope of the systems used, including the specific decisions and categories of decisions they take or support (such as selection, recruitment, assignment of tasks, productivity control, promotions);
(iii) all inputs, criteria, variables, correlations, and parameters used by the systems in producing those outputs;
(iv) the logic used by the systems to produce their outputs, including, but not limited to, weightings of different inputs and parameters;
(v) the outputs produced by the systems (e.g., decisions, recommendations, scores);
(vi) the consequences that the decisions taken or assisted by the algorithmic management systems may have on the individual;
(vii) the existence and extent of human involvement in decision - making processes involving the systems, and the competence, authority, and accountability of the human persons involved;
(viii) if the systems are provided by or sourced from a third party (e.g., a software vendor or an open-source software package), or operated by a third party, the name of the third party and the name or common description of the software
(ix) information about individuals’ rights to receive information about the systems and decisions (or other outputs produced by those systems) affecting them, to request human review of the decisions or other outputs, and to contest the decisions or other outputs; and information about how to exercise those rights;
(x) any other available avenues for recourse, such as rights to engage with relevant competent authorities (such as the data protection officer, worker representatives, data protection authority, labour body, or equality body) or to judicial remedy;
(xi) contact information for the relevant competent authorities.
2. The notice shall be concise, transparent, and intelligible, using clear and .....plain language, and made available in an easily and continuously accessible electronic format
What does this mean in practice?
- Establishes individual notice obligations at specified points throughout the employment relationship.
- Stipulates the type of information to be provided in notices, including the logic used by the systems to produce their outputs and details about third-party software vendors.
- Requires that notices are ‘concise, transparent and intelligible, using clear and plain language’ and available in electronic format.
Real-world examples of policy option 3
Data protection law: provides data subjects with the right to be informed about personal data processing (EU GDPR, art 12-14); the right to access a copy of their personal information (EU GDPR, art 15); meaningful information about the logic, significance and consequences of automated decision-making (EU GDPR, art 15(1)(h)).
Labour law: imposes notification and disclosure obligations on digital labour platforms to inform platform workers about automated monitoring and decision-making systems at three stages of the employment relationship (Platform Work Directive, art 9).
Labour law in Spain: requires digital delivery platforms to disclose information to workers about an AI system where their use in decision-making (including profiling) may impact working conditions or access to and maintenance of employment (Royal Decree-Law 9/2021).
This site is part of a project that has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No. 947806).
If you have any questions or feedback about this site or our research, please get in touch by emailing ai.work@law.ox.ac.uk.