Challenging Compliance with International Intellectual Property Norms in Investor-State Dispute Settlement, Dr Henning Grosse Ruse-Khan, University of Cambridge
ABSTRACT : Enforcing intellectual property (IP) rights abroad is not easy – not least because international IP treaties do not create global rights that can invoked in national courts. International investment law offers potential routes for overcoming these hurdles. Whenever investment treaties include IP rights as an investment and allow for investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS), investors can challenge host state measures affecting their IP rights in ISDS proceedings. As this article will show, this in turn offers a unique opportunity for invoking the standards of protection under international investment agreements (IIAs) to challenge host state compliance with international IP treaties.
While challenging national IP regimes is an attractive option for right holders, these challenges potentially amount to a sea-change for the international IP regime and cause serious concern for host states. I however argue that most of the routes pursued by right holders under IIAs are unlikely to be successful. Investment protection standards such as fair and equitable treatment, umbrella clauses and most-favored nation treatment should not be construed to allow invoking alleged breaches of international IP norms in ISDS. Some IIAs however contain clauses that subject expropriation claims against compulsory licenses and other IP limitations to a test of consistency with the international IP rules governing these limitations. As they offer the only feasible route for investors to challenge host state compliance with international IP treaties, I review the implications of these clauses, recent reform proposals and suggest alternative mechanisms for aligning international IP and investment protection based on general international law.
Fragmented, Inflexible, and often Irrelevant: Towards Needed Copyright Reform in the EU, Professor Christophe Geiger, Director General and Director of the Research Department of the Centre for International Intellectual Property Studies (CEIPI)
Are We Running Out of Trademarks? An Empirical Study of Trademark Depletion, Professor Barton Beebe & Professor Jeanne Fromer, New York University School of Law
Shavers, Bricks and Highchair Tricks? The Shape of things to come in EU Trade Mark Law?, Professor Dirk Visser, Leiden Law School and advocaat with Visser Schaap & Kreijger
Principles Underlying Copyright Exceptions in the European Union and what could lie ahead?, Professor Severine Dusollier, University of Namur and SciencesPo Paris
Copyright in the EU Digital Single Market. The End of Territoriality?, Professor Bernt Hugenholtz, University of Amsterdam
The British Patent System during the Industrial Revolution, Sean Bottomley, Institute of Advanced Study in Toulouse
Copyright Formalities: Fairness or Forfeiture, Professor Jane C Ginsburg, Columbia University School of Law
Striving for a Better Balance: changes in the catalogue of Trade Mark limitations and exceptions, Professor Annette Kur, Max Planck Institute for Innovation and Competition