State legitimacy, law, and the political subject

Event date
17 January 2022
Event time
Oxford week
HT 1
Faculty Members
Members of the University
Postgraduate Students
Undergraduate Students
N P Adams, University of Virginia
NP Adams (University of Virginia) State legitimacy, law, and the political subject 17 January 2022 | 12:00 EST | 17:00 GMT Theories of state legitimacy require a deontic characterization of both the state and the state’s subject. Classically this characterization is that a legitimate state has the moral right to rule and state subjects correlatively possess a general duty to obey the law. Partly in response to skepticism about such a duty, philosophers have increasingly turned to revised characterizations. These revisionist accounts, however, still focus on the political subject as an exclusively legal subject. In this paper, I argue that this reduction of the political subject to the legal subject is untenable. A successful theory of state legitimacy must characterize our relations to the state in a way that recognizes our necessarily extralegal relation to the state and to the legal regime, including in our collective constituent power. Further, such a theory should take itself seriously as an ideology: as both appealing to and constructing political subjects’ identity. This expands the question of deontic status beyond Hohfeldian incidents to what kind of person our states require us to be.

This event

Organised by
Oxford Seminars in Jurisprudence

Found within

General Interest